Most of us loathe the dreaded love triangle, which appears particularly prevalent in YA fiction. Inspired by some discussions I’ve seen on Twitter this week, here are my top 5 alternate takes on a love triangle that would make it much more palatable to me!
1. The boy is the one in the middle for a change. Ah, the agony of his feels as he is forced to choose between the mysterious new girl and his attractive childhood best friend… *snorts*
2. A love triangle when one of the suitors is like “You know what? I’m out.” They get tired of being strung along, and decide that if the MC is not going to make a decision, then they’re bowing out for their own self-preservation.
3. LGBQTA protagonists in the dreaded triangle of lurve. For instance, a bi girl torn between a princess who runs a secret spy ring and a dashing knight with a tragic backstory! Yeahhhh! Authors, there’s a whole damn alphabet at your disposal.
4. A … one sided triangle? That doesn’t sound right! (Mathematically, that would just be a line!) I’m referring to instances where it’s not two people in love with the same person, but person X in love with person Y who doesn’t return X’s feelings and is actually in serious feels for person Z. Capiche?
5. And, my favourite scenario of all: the two competing dudes realize that all their posturing and growling at each other for the heroine’s attention is ACTUALLY to hide the fact that they like each other very very much so they shack up and become happy gay farmers while the heroine goes on to slay dragons and conquer the world, single and damn happy about it, thank you very much.
+ BONUS
All three of the protagonists decide to screw society’s expectations, and form a very happy, very supportive polyamorous relationship. WOOT!
What about you, lovely readers? Any other configurations you think I should have included?
The happy gay farmers scenario has occurred to me too. Though it was singing lumberjacks in my version ;) Have a great weekend!
LikeLike
BAHAHA. It’s totally my favourite scenario! <3
LikeLike
What a fun post! I would love to read number 5 in a book hahaha. I think I might have seen it in a yaoi manga once XD
LikeLike
Haha, so would I! Maybe I should start writing… :P
LikeLike
I’d like option #5, please. :D What about the two people who like each other, but they each love another? What about that one? *coughsemberintheashescoughs*
LikeLike
Baaahahaha!! Yes!!! Now THOSE are love triangles I could really appreciate!! :)
LikeLike
Yay! Glad you agree!
LikeLike
BAHAHAHA. Hannah, this post totally made my day! XD #2–Hell yes. Every time I read about love triangles, I imagine what I would do in those situations. I’d definitely quit. #5–YES. Bonus–I love this one! It’s totally possible in real life, too.
LikeLike
Aw, thank you so much! I had a lot of fun imagining up different scenarios. Maybe someday we’ll see them in a book or two?
LikeLike
I totally love everything here except 1, because even if the roles were reversed, it’s just the same :P But seriously number 2 to the bonus… YESSSSSSSSSSSSS! And I love it when the two love interests like the heroine but are not so showy about it and the heroine is clueless about their feelings and therefore has no romantic feelings for them at the start:) Or they don’t say it outright… the story goes on and they just interject gestures here and there. It makes my heart pound more!
Faye at The Social Potato
LikeLike
Ha yes, you’re totally right, it would be exactly the same – but I haven’t yet seen a boy torn between two ladies, so hopefully the thought process would be interesting. Love your suggestions – there are so many ways authors could create interesting and nuanced love triangles!
LikeLike
A … one sided triangle? That doesn’t sound right! (Mathematically, that would just be a line!) -You said
Really?!?!? I snorted milk out of my nose HAHAHAHHAA I loooove this post!
LikeLike
Baha. I had some trouble with the phrasing! XD
LikeLike
This is a great post.
I don’t mind love triangles, but that could be because I don’t read a ton of YA. But I would LOVE to see scenarios 1 and 5, especially 5! If you ever read a book that includes that, I hope you’ll let us know! :)
Angie
LikeLike
Haha, if I ever encounter a book that does scenario #5, I WILL SHOUT IT FROM THE ROOFTOPS!
Thanks for stopping by!
LikeLike
Haha, all of these! I would read these and love them at the drop of a hat!
I think a love triangle where one character realises they’re not into it… I mean i guess it’s a version of #2 to a degree but, like, idk I would love more mistakes… more realisations that they’re just good friends and it doesn’t work romanitcally and that’s okay.
:)
LikeLike
Thank you!
Yup, I totally agree that we need more scenarios where people think they have lurve feelings, but it turns out to just be friendly affection, and that they are better off as friends. Learning from mistakes is part of life.
LikeLike
Hahahaha this is great. Number 5 clearly wins!
C.J.
Sarcasm & Lemons
LikeLike
Baha. YES! Tis my favourite scenario!
LikeLike
The Bonus is what my dreams are made of! More triads please!!! I’ve only read one in YA, but a few in Adult.
Yes, for the boys choosing each other! That would be awesome! All of this tension between the three of them leads to longing glances instead of glares, lingering touches instead of punches! *my heart*
LikeLike
Totally! I think there’s so much that could be done to make love triangles more interesting instead of choosing the same old typical fare. Love your suggestions!
LikeLike
Hahaha those are some amazing ideas! I would love to see #5 and #2.
LikeLike
Why thank you! Quite frankly, I’m happy to see any kind of variation on the standard love triangle fare these days.
LikeLike
#5 would be so amazing. I would just love some new geometry. If I have to read one more book about a girl torn between a childhood friend who’s in love with her and a Mysterious Brooding New Guy, I’ll lose it.
Thanks so much for stopping by! Jen @ YA Romantics
LikeLike
YES! Yes to everything you said. There are so many ways to spice up the same-old live triangle tropes.
LikeLike